A debate is a productive way to weigh opposing views on an issue and to assess the logical arguments supporting each view. Two sides to an issue are presented – one side argues in favour of a proposition, and one side argues against. Each side can be represented by one person, or alternatively, a team The highest quality debates usually result from comparing two extreme positions. Debates can take several formats. One popular format is the Oxford-style debate: http://www.ox.ac.uk/oxford_debates/. Debates usually have strict rules and timing and are judged by one or two moderators. Audience participation and/or scoring of the debate should be built into the session agenda and the debate teams must work together before the session to prepare their arguments.
Time:
- 90 mins; or
- 60 mins
Optimal Layout:
- Two podiums; with a table next to each podiums for the debater(s) to sit;
- Rows of chairs for the audience;
- Roaming microphones to capture questions/comments from the audience (depending on the debate format used);
- If speakers are participating remotely, the use of video/audio conferencing;
- Printouts and/or a shared online space for collaborative drafting/notetaking;
- Online participation station.
Note on Diversity Criteria: Debates naturally require two speakers, or speaker teams, with opposing views. The debaters and judge panel (if applicable) should reflect diversity.
Example: WS 196 On cybersecurity, who has got our back?: A debate [Description; Video, Transcript & Report]